The FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center logged 56,478 complaints in 2025 from people who paid for something that never came, or shipped something and never got paid. Those complaints carried $503,373,587 in reported losses. On the same ledger, investment fraud came to $8,648,617,756, about seventeen times as much, and nobody had to stand in a checkout line to lose it.
Black Friday lands on November 27 this year, and the warnings about fake storefronts and phantom packages are already running. They are not wrong. They are just pointed at the cheaper end of the problem. The FBI’s 2025 Internet Crime Report counts 1,008,597 complaints and $20.877 billion in reported losses, an average of $20,699 per complaint, and the categories that drain the most money rarely involve a shopping cart at all.
The ledger, sorted by dollars
Where a phantom package ranks when the FBI adds up the year
IC3 sorts every complaint into a crime type, and its Appendix C says plainly that each complaint will only have one crime type. That makes the loss column a fair way to see where the money went. The table below ranks the report’s crime types by reported losses. The shopping category, Non-Payment/Non-Delivery, is bolded. The share column divides each category by the report’s $20.877 billion total, and the average column divides losses by complaints.
| Rank by losses | IC3 crime type | Complaints | Reported losses | Share of $20.877B | Average per complaint |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Investment | 72,984 | $8,648.6M | 41.4% | $118,500 |
| 2 | Business Email Compromise | 24,768 | $3,046.6M | 14.6% | $123,005 |
| 3 | Tech/Customer Support | 47,794 | $2,134.7M | 10.2% | $44,664 |
| 4 | Personal Data Breach | 67,456 | $1,314.9M | 6.3% | $19,493 |
| 5 | Confidence/Romance | 23,159 | $929.3M | 4.5% | $40,126 |
| 6 | Government Impersonation | 32,424 | $797.9M | 3.8% | $24,610 |
| 7 | Other | 20,031 | $512.1M | 2.5% | $25,568 |
| 8 | Non-Payment/Non-Delivery | 56,478 | $503.4M | 2.4% | $8,913 |
| 9 | Data Breach | 3,963 | $435.2M | 2.1% | $109,826 |
| 10 | Employment | 24,688 | $362.9M | 1.7% | $14,701 |
| 11 | Credit Card/Check Fraud | 18,774 | $282.7M | 1.4% | $15,056 |
| 12 | Real Estate | 12,368 | $275.1M | 1.3% | $22,244 |
Source: FBI IC3, 2025 Internet Crime Report, crime-type table. Shares and averages calculated by x9m8 from the report’s figures. Rows below rank 12 omitted.
Two numbers in that table pull against each other. By count, Non-Payment/Non-Delivery is the fifth most common complaint in the report, behind phishing, extortion, investment and personal data breach. By dollars it sits eighth. The average shopping complaint comes to under $9,000, while an average investment complaint runs past $118,000.
Put another way, the average investment complaint is about thirteen times the size of the average shopping complaint.
IC3 defines the shopping category in two halves. Non-delivery means payment is sent and the goods or services are never received, or are of less quality. Non-payment runs the other direction: goods go out and the money never arrives, which is the side small sellers on marketplaces live with all season.

Seventeen to one
The category that swallows four of every ten reported dollars
Investment fraud is the boiler room under the building. IC3 defines it as a deceptive practice that induces investors to make purchases based on false information, and in 2025 it accounted for about 41 percent of all reported losses. Inside that category, cryptocurrency investment fraud alone drew 61,559 complaints and $7.228 billion, according to the report. Across every crime type, IC3 tallied $11.366 billion in losses tied to cryptocurrency.
Run the arithmetic one more way. At investment fraud’s 2025 pace, the whole year’s shopping-fraud losses would be matched in about three weeks.
The next rows down tell a similar story. Business email compromise, the scheme in which a fake invoice or a spoofed executive reroutes a wire, took $3.05 billion. Tech and customer support fraud, defined by IC3 as a subject posing as technical or customer support, took $2.13 billion. Confidence and romance fraud, where someone believes they are in a relationship and is tricked into sending money, came to $929.3 million, nearly twice the shopping total on fewer than half as many complaints.
Age sharpens the picture. IC3 counted 201,266 complaints from people 60 and older, with $7.748 billion in losses and a $38,500 average. That one age group accounts for about 37 percent of the national total. The report also says 12,444 complainants in that group lost more than $100,000 each.
None of those schemes need a holiday. They run on patience, on a voice that calls back every week, on a dashboard that shows a balance climbing toward a number that never existed.
Two agencies, two totals
The FBI says $20.9 billion, the FTC says $15.9 billion, and both are right about their own pile
The Federal Trade Commission keeps a second ledger. In March 2026 testimony before the Joint Economic Committee, the Federal Trade Commission said consumers reported $15.9 billion in losses in 2025, across 3 million fraud reports. Readers can be forgiven for wondering which number is the real one.
The agencies describe their own data in ways that explain the gap. The FBI’s report notes, in its ransomware section and again in an appendix, that its figures only represent what entities report to the FBI via IC3 and do not account for entities reporting directly to FBI field offices. The FTC’s Consumer Sentinel Network collects reports directly from consumers and from data contributors. The FTC’s written testimony then lists who those contributors are, and the footnote names the FBI’s own complaint center: CSN government data contributors include the Federal Bureau of Investigation’s Internet Crime Center (IC3), alongside the Postal Inspection Service, the Social Security Administration, state attorneys general and companies such as Microsoft, Western Union and Zelle.
The two totals overlap, like two meters on pipes that share some of the same water, and neither agency’s public material says by how much. Adding them together would be a mistake, and so would treating the difference as proof one agency is wrong. The FBI’s report also covers businesses and organizations, from ransomware victims to companies hit by business email compromise, while the FTC’s figure describes consumers.
The FTC’s own ranking lines up with the FBI’s. Its testimony says the top fraud by aggregate consumer losses is investment scams, at more than $7.9 billion, and that approximately half of all reported fraud losses for 2025 trace to them. Imposter scams were the most reported category, with more than 1 million reports and over $3.5 billion lost.
Then the FTC says the harder thing. Its testimony states that these reported fraud losses are just a fraction of what consumers actually lose, and that the agency has estimated the overall cost of fraud to consumers for 2024 could be as high as $195.9 billion. A footnote cites research finding that only 4.8 percent of mass-market fraud victims complained to a Better Business Bureau or a government agency.

The case for worrying about the shopping cart anyway
Small losses, many people, and the dollars that never get reported
The strongest argument against this post’s direction is sitting in that footnote. If most victims never file, the small losses are the ones most likely to go missing. Someone out $60 on a fake sneaker site has little reason to fill out a federal complaint form. Someone out $400,000 to a crypto platform has every reason. The ledger may undercount shopping fraud by more than it undercounts investment fraud, and the reports do not say by how much in either case.
Volume matters too. Non-Payment/Non-Delivery ranks fifth by complaint count, so more people file about lost packages and unpaid orders than about romance scams, business email compromise or government impersonation. An $8,913 average is not small money for most households in December.
There is also a door between the two worlds. The FTC’s testimony says consumers lost the highest aggregate amounts by sending money to scammers via bank payments, with cryptocurrency next, while credit cards were the payment method people named most often. A cheap shopping scam that harvests a card number, a phone number and a sense of trust is a lead list for whatever comes next. The reports do not trace how often one leads to the other, and this post won’t pretend they do.
The fair reading is narrower than “shopping scams don’t matter.” They are common, and a purchase made on a credit card can be disputed. The FTC’s testimony puts the largest aggregate losses on bank payments and crypto, and its shopping guide lists wire transfers, payment apps and cryptocurrency among the methods scammers push because they make it hard to get money back.
What the FTC and FBI tell holiday shoppers to do
Plain advice, mostly about how to pay
Most of the official advice comes down to the payment rail, because the rail decides whether money can come back.
- Pay by credit card where possible. The FTC says paying by credit card best protects you and your money in case of a scam, and that charges for merchandise never received can be disputed. Its guidance says to write to the card company so the letter arrives within 60 days of the first bill showing the error. The FBI’s holiday page gives the same instruction: use a credit card when shopping online and check your statement regularly.
- Treat certain payment demands as the warning itself. The FTC says to never buy anything from online sellers that insist you can only pay with gift cards, by wire transfers, and lists payment apps and cryptocurrency among the red flags. The FBI says to never wire money directly to a seller and to avoid prepaid gift cards.
- Look up the seller before the ad does the talking. The FTC’s November 2025 holiday alert says to search online for the seller’s name and the website URL the ad sends you to. Its broader guide suggests searching the company name with the words “complaint” or “scam,” and warns against relying on star ratings because some reviews are fake.
- Check the address bar. The FBI says to check each website’s URL to make sure it’s legitimate and secure, and not to click suspicious links or attachments in emails, on websites or on social media.
- Keep the paperwork. The FTC notes that a receipt and order confirmation number can help you get your money back. The FTC’s broader shopping guide adds that when no shipping time is promised, an FTC rule requires the seller to ship within 30 days of getting the order and payment.
- Move fast if money already went out. IC3’s report tells victims to contact their financial institution immediately and request a recall of the funds, and to file at IC3 regardless of the amount lost, with full transaction details.
That last point carries over to the large frauds. The FTC’s testimony describes IC3’s Recovery Asset Team, which can start a process called the Financial Fraud Kill Chain to alert banks and try to freeze money sent to scammers. In 2024, according to the testimony, that process ran on 2,651 incidents and froze $469 million of $651.5 million in reported losses, or about 72 percent.

The other eleven months
Black Friday gets the warnings because it has a date on it
A shopping scam has a calendar, or at least the warnings about it do. Retail has a season, so the fraud that rides on retail gets a season of public service announcements, local news segments and reminder emails from the bank. Investment and romance fraud keep no calendar. They are slow, they lean on loneliness or ambition, and they can do their worst work on an ordinary Tuesday in March.
The same rules hold for both. Money sent by wire, crypto or gift card is hard to pull back. Anyone who insists on those rails, whether a holiday storefront or a new friend with a trading app, is telling on themselves. Related reading on x9m8 covers what courts require before a data breach lawsuit can go anywhere, how to make data brokers delete personal information, and the law on AI voice cloning for anyone worried about a familiar voice on the phone asking for money.
The FBI says it now averages almost 3,000 complaints per day. Spread evenly over 2025, about 155 a day involved a package that never came or a payment that never arrived. Most of the money will be about something else. Which scam has come closest to a household on this side of the screen: the fake storefront, or the patient one that calls back?
For informational purposes only — consult a licensed attorney or financial advisor.
Sources
- FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center, 2025 Internet Crime Report: https://www.ic3.gov/AnnualReport/Reports/2025_IC3Report.pdf
- Federal Trade Commission, “FTC Testifies Before Joint Economic Committee on Agency’s Efforts to Combat Fraud” (March 25, 2026): https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2026/03/ftc-testifies-joint-economic-committee-agencys-efforts-combat-fraud
- Federal Trade Commission, prepared statement, Joint Economic Committee hearing on the rising scam economy: https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/ftc_gov/pdf/ftc-testimony-jec-hearing-on-the-rising-scam-economy.pdf
- FTC Consumer Advice, “How to avoid an online shopping scam this holiday season” (Nov. 25, 2025): https://consumer.ftc.gov/consumer-alerts/2025/11/how-avoid-online-shopping-scam-holiday-season
- FTC Consumer Advice, “Online Shopping”: https://consumer.ftc.gov/articles/online-shopping
- FBI, “Holiday Scams”: https://www.fbi.gov/how-we-can-help-you/scams-and-safety/common-frauds-and-scams/holiday-scams
