I never planned on a Z4. My lease on a 5 Series was up, and I wanted a hybrid SUV, the X5. The chip shortage had other plans. BMW stock was thin everywhere and thinner on Long Island, and the wait for the SUV I wanted was running around six months. So I walked out of Competition BMW with a two-seat roadster instead. Fast, fun, gorgeous, and the wrong car for how I actually live.


How I ended up in a Z4
My 5 Series lease was ending and I wanted something new, not six months from now. My sales guy at Competition BMW was explaining the wait, and the whole time I was looking past him at a Z4 M40i sitting on the showroom floor.
I’m 6’1″. The Z4 is a small car with two seats. But I had always thought it would be a great car to drive, and it was the start of summer. Top down, fast car, nothing else available. The hell with it.
Looking back, that was frustration talking. I said give me this one, and I leased it. Three years later, I turned it in.




The car I had
Frozen Grey II Metallic, BMW’s matte grey, on 19-inch M dual-spoke Jet Black wheels with staggered performance tires, red brake calipers and a Moonlight Black soft top. Inside, Magma Red Vernasca leather with black contrast stitching. BMW’s owner records list the Premium, Driving Assistance and Shadowline packages and a Harman Kardon surround sound system.
It is a striking car. Parked in a driveway it looks like a small, angry wedge, and with the top down and the doors open, the red interior is the first thing anyone sees from across a lot.
The M40i is the top Z4 in the American lineup. Kelley Blue Book lists it at 382 horsepower and 368 lb-ft of torque, a 0 to 60 time of 3.9 seconds, a curb weight of 3,457 pounds and a top speed of 155 mph. The engine is a turbocharged 3.0-liter inline-six driving the rear wheels through an eight-speed automatic.




Getting in at 6’1″
Coming out of a 5 Series, and planning on an SUV, the first thing I noticed was how low you sit. Getting down into that seat was not normal for me. The cabin was a bit tight from day one.
I dealt with it, because the car earned it. For the first few weeks of that summer, it was awesome.

Fast, and it handles
The Z4 handled great and it was fast, and with the top down it was a blast. TrueCar’s review calls the M40i’s six silky smooth and one of the best engines available. HotCars cites a 0 to 60 of 3.8 seconds and a quarter mile of 12.3 seconds, and in a car this small, you feel every bit of it.
Reviewers mostly agree it grips hard and turns in sharply. Evo credits it with accurate steering, strong performance and grip, while warning not to expect Porsche Boxster levels of feel. Carbuyer says the M40i has lots of power and a muscular nature, but that many drivers will prefer the feel of lighter rivals. Exotic Car Trader points out the 2022 Z4 was never offered with a manual.
None of that ever bothered me. The driving was never the problem.



The weather problem
A few weeks in, driving out east in August, I started to figure something out. Anything over 70 degrees with the top down is hot. At 80, it’s hotter. At 90 and above, it ain’t happening.
So the top goes up and the AC goes on. And that is a different car. Low to the ground, two seats, a fabric roof a few inches over my head. It felt tight and closed in, a little claustrophobic, and small on the road next to everything else. I didn’t like it.
Then the weather turned the other way. Below 60, the top-down drive is too cold and too windy. So the top goes back up, the heat goes on, and I’m back in the same small box.
That left a window. Somewhere between 70 and 80 degrees, top down, the Z4 is exactly the car I imagined on the showroom floor. On Long Island, there are not many days like that.



The X5 takes over
Winter was coming, and I knew it was going to be tough in that little car. I had no real choice. I ordered the X5, the plug-in hybrid I wanted in the first place, to be practical for driving to work. That review is coming.
From then on, the Z4 was a weekend car, and only a top-down weekend car. When the weather sat in that 70 to 80 window, it came out. When it didn’t, it stayed in the garage. Matte paint does not forgive a dirty sponge, so on the days it did come out, it usually got washed by hand on the driveway before it went back in.
When I turned the car in at the end of the lease, it had very few miles on it. That says more than anything else in this review.
What I’d check on a test drive
A ten-minute spin on a nice day will sell anyone on a Z4. It sold me. The test drive should look more like the year you’ll actually own it.
- Drive it with the top up. Put the roof up, turn on the AC, and spend twenty minutes on a highway next to trucks and SUVs. That is the car on every hot day and every cold one.
- Get in and out a few times. At 6’1″, the low seat was the first thing I noticed coming from a 5 Series. Do it in a tight parking spot, not just in an open showroom.
- Count your days. Think honestly about how many days a year sit between 70 and 80 where you live. That number is how often the car is at its best.
- Know your backup. If there is no second car for work, winter and errands, the Z4 has to do all of it, and that is a lot to ask of two seats and a soft top.
Living with two seats
There is no back seat. TrueCar lists cargo space at 9.9 cubic feet, which covers a weekend bag or a work bag and not much else. Fuel economy is better than a 382-horsepower car should get, and TrueCar quotes 22 mpg city and 29 highway for the M40i.
The Z4 also shares its bones with the current Toyota Supra. Carbuyer notes the two were developed side by side, with enough differences to give each its own personality. The Supra has a fixed roof. The Z4 trades some cargo space and a little rigidity for a top that disappears in seconds, which is the whole reason to buy one, and also, for me, the whole problem.
Price, warranty and buying used
Edmunds lists the 2022 Z4 sDrive M40i at a starting MSRP of $63,700. The four-cylinder sDrive30i started lower, and CarGurus puts its base price at $49,990. HotCars notes that the 2022 model carried over with no major changes from the year before, and TrueCar lists the basic warranty at four years or 50,000 miles.
That makes a used, low-mile M40i worth a look. Cars like mine, weekend toys that sat out the bad weather, are out there. As with any used convertible, check the top, its seals and the drains, and look hard at the tires.
Who should buy one
The Z4 M40i is a great car with a very specific job. If you have another car for work and winter, and you live somewhere with a long stretch of 70-degree days, it is a fast, beautiful, top-down weekend car, and it will make you happy.
If it has to be your only car, or you’re tall and like room around you, think hard. With the top up, it’s a small, low, closed-in two-seater. On Long Island, the top is up a lot more than you’d expect.
Would I do it again? Not as my only car, and not out of frustration on a showroom floor. As a weekend car on the right day, absolutely.
Sources
- BMW My Garage owner account: vehicle features and options
- Kelley Blue Book, 2022 BMW Z4 specs
- Edmunds, 2022 BMW Z4 sDrive M40i specs
- TrueCar, 2022 BMW Z4 review
- HotCars, things to know before buying the 2022 BMW Z4
- Exotic Car Trader, 2022 BMW Z4 M40i review
- Evo, BMW Z4 performance and 0-60
- Carbuyer, BMW Z4 engines, drive and performance
- Carbuyer, BMW Z4 roadster engines and performance
- CarGurus, 2022 BMW Z4 reviews and specs
